Cabbage Logo
Back to Cabbage Site

Csound and Cabbage beta - incompatibilities?

#21

This would be great! Would there be any serious downsides of using Csound 6.15 with the recent Cabbage? If not this could be an emergency solution for me :slight_smile:

#22

When I run the fixed code it works fine, but I am seeing an issue whenever I re-save it. Iā€™m just going to run it though the bugger. I can change the FFT size without issues, but re-saving it definitely causing a crashā€¦

I donā€™t think. There are some updates and fixes, and one area related to Cabbage, but only if you plan to distribute plugins with plugin opcodes. Iā€™ve asked on the csound-dev list. Iā€™ll let you know what they say.

#23

Sorry if I missed something, I tried 1.0 -> 1. Should I change something else?

#24

:rofl: Right, I didnā€™t mean the number, you need to change the identifier to camelCase!

#25

Silly me. Thanks! That makes it work but changing FFT size still causes crash.

#26

Big big thanks!

#27

This one looks like a Csound bug to me. When I revert back to 6.15 it seems to work fine. I wonā€™t be able to debug the Csound code until I have access to my Linux machine again, which wonā€™t be for a week or so.

Csound 6.16 is doing a real number on you! :man_facepalming:

#28

Oh, thanks for figuring it all out! In a way it makes it easier, we can blame it all on the Csound update and I could use the old Csound. That alternative would definitely be feasible for me if there are no hidden issues. Iā€™m not distributing for now, but would like to make some crazy music during summer :slight_smile:

#29

Iā€™d like to narrow down what the problem was though. I will when I get a chance. :+1: You just concentrate on making crazy music! :wink:

#30

Super! Thanks!!!
BTW. some examples like BarModel also no longer work with Csound 6.16
[edit] it might actually not be Csound to blame in this case?

#31

What makes you think so?

[edit] I just tested with both Csound 6.15 and 6.16 and it works fine for me.

#32

@Samo, can you try this version of Csound. Victor just uploaded it. It has the fix for the turnoff issues. He just needs confirmation that itā€™s Ok before doing a proper point release. :+1:

#33

Thanks! My instrument seem to play well now with the Csound you linked :slight_smile:

The crashing on FFT length change is still there and some examples still donā€™t work for me - these is no form showing up (tried only in IDE with old and new Csound). And I canā€™t stop the instrument, I mean pressing stop button doesnā€™t stop it. Iā€™m wondering if it could be due to my altered paths (user files) in settings:

image
image1556Ɨ948 386 KB

#34

I donā€™t think that will have any effect on it. I tried with the latest beta and the bar model example worked fine. What other examples donā€™t work?

#35

See some more examples in the screen shot:

image
image2246Ɨ72 25.3 KB

#36

Something very strange going on here. While the BarModel one worked fine for me, many of these donā€™t show at all. Iā€™ll take a look first thing tomorrow.

#37

Changing Csound to version 6.16 fixes this issue. Argghhhā€¦

And 6.16.1 fixes these problems. Boy, thereā€™s a few hours I wonā€™t get back. Turns out all of those examples were using turnoff

#38

So sorry for your lost time! Maybe you sorted it? But for some reason those instruments still donā€™t show at all for me. Just tried TR-808 and MiniPops with Csound 6.16.1 and latest Cabbage 2.7.3 (omitted installation of Csound there - which displays 6.15). Since I donā€™t use these examples it is not acute for me, but maybe there is something else going on?

#39

Donā€™t worry, that wasnā€™t your fault. I should have tried this sooner.

Me too, and itā€™s the same for me :frowning: Itā€™s definitely an issue with Csound, as it works fine with 6.15. Also, if I comment out the calls to turnoff it works fine. So I guess weā€™re not out of the woods yet in terms of turnoffā€¦

#40

Thanks for checking. Maybe time to call in the other superheroes?